<article>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#article09_06_24_1831232</id>
	<title>35,000-Year-Old Flute Is Oldest Music Instrument Ever Found</title>
	<author>timothy</author>
	<datestamp>1245868800000</datestamp>
	<htmltext><a href="http://blog.instantcognition.com/" rel="nofollow">Omomyid</a> writes <i>"The <a href="http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20090624/sc\_afp/sciencearcheologymusicgermany\_20090624174002">AFP is reporting the discovery of a 35,000 year-old flute</a>, made from a vulture wing bone. The context described makes it sound like a musician's shop. There were also fragments of ivory-based flutes and flint tools. Being at least 35KYO this bone flute beats the previous oldest-known musical instrument by at least 5,000 years and puts it very close to the beginning of the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aurignacian">Aurignacian culture</a>."</i></htmltext>
<tokenext>Omomyid writes " The AFP is reporting the discovery of a 35,000 year-old flute , made from a vulture wing bone .
The context described makes it sound like a musician 's shop .
There were also fragments of ivory-based flutes and flint tools .
Being at least 35KYO this bone flute beats the previous oldest-known musical instrument by at least 5,000 years and puts it very close to the beginning of the Aurignacian culture .
"</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Omomyid writes "The AFP is reporting the discovery of a 35,000 year-old flute, made from a vulture wing bone.
The context described makes it sound like a musician's shop.
There were also fragments of ivory-based flutes and flint tools.
Being at least 35KYO this bone flute beats the previous oldest-known musical instrument by at least 5,000 years and puts it very close to the beginning of the Aurignacian culture.
"</sentencetext>
</article>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456785</id>
	<title>RiAA...</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245874020000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Insightful</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Has the RIAA claimed ownership rights over the music they made with it?</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Has the RIAA claimed ownership rights over the music they made with it ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Has the RIAA claimed ownership rights over the music they made with it?</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661</id>
	<title>Complex vs Simple.</title>
	<author>B5\_geek</author>
	<datestamp>1245873420000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Funny</modclass>
	<modscore>2</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>I understand that this could be considered definitive proof of an 'instrument', but surely they don't discount that beating two sticks together can be considered as being musical either.</p><p>Consider this: prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man.  If all electrical devices stop working tomorrow, a significant \% of the population will be dead within 4 weeks.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>I understand that this could be considered definitive proof of an 'instrument ' , but surely they do n't discount that beating two sticks together can be considered as being musical either.Consider this : prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man .
If all electrical devices stop working tomorrow , a significant \ % of the population will be dead within 4 weeks .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>I understand that this could be considered definitive proof of an 'instrument', but surely they don't discount that beating two sticks together can be considered as being musical either.Consider this: prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man.
If all electrical devices stop working tomorrow, a significant \% of the population will be dead within 4 weeks.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456415</id>
	<title>Interesting!</title>
	<author>squiggly12</author>
	<datestamp>1245872580000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Insightful</modclass>
	<modscore>3</modscore>
	<htmltext>It makes a person wonder just how long ago music was enjoyed (besides whistling or singing) or did we just grunt our way around?</htmltext>
<tokenext>It makes a person wonder just how long ago music was enjoyed ( besides whistling or singing ) or did we just grunt our way around ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>It makes a person wonder just how long ago music was enjoyed (besides whistling or singing) or did we just grunt our way around?</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458261</id>
	<title>Re:Complex vs Simple.</title>
	<author>sznupi</author>
	<datestamp>1245836520000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Large \% of population would be dead simply because there would be no place for them, no resources, in pre-industrial society.</p><p>Are members of the "protected tribes" necessarily more intelligent?</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Large \ % of population would be dead simply because there would be no place for them , no resources , in pre-industrial society.Are members of the " protected tribes " necessarily more intelligent ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Large \% of population would be dead simply because there would be no place for them, no resources, in pre-industrial society.Are members of the "protected tribes" necessarily more intelligent?</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456519</id>
	<title>My ancestors used mammoth bones</title>
	<author>WillAffleckUW</author>
	<datestamp>1245872940000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Informativ</modclass>
	<modscore>2</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>But then, we got those when we rode dinosaurs with Jesus.</p><p>Mind you, it was hard lugging around a large mammoth flute.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>But then , we got those when we rode dinosaurs with Jesus.Mind you , it was hard lugging around a large mammoth flute .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>But then, we got those when we rode dinosaurs with Jesus.Mind you, it was hard lugging around a large mammoth flute.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28464423</id>
	<title>So much history we don't know...</title>
	<author>master\_p</author>
	<datestamp>1245927900000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>If humanity started 35,000 or more years ago...</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>If humanity started 35,000 or more years ago.. .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>If humanity started 35,000 or more years ago...</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456625</id>
	<title>Neanderthal invented musical instruments</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245873300000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Informativ</modclass>
	<modscore>5</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>It is the oldest for the Homo sapiens, but there were flutes found on Neanderthal sites, much older flutes.<br>http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/376813/neanderthal\_flute\_the\_oldest\_musical.html</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>It is the oldest for the Homo sapiens , but there were flutes found on Neanderthal sites , much older flutes.http : //www.associatedcontent.com/article/376813/neanderthal \ _flute \ _the \ _oldest \ _musical.html</tokentext>
<sentencetext>It is the oldest for the Homo sapiens, but there were flutes found on Neanderthal sites, much older flutes.http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/376813/neanderthal\_flute\_the\_oldest\_musical.html</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456601</id>
	<title>Oblig YEC reesponse</title>
	<author>MaXintosh</author>
	<datestamp>1245873240000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Funny</modclass>
	<modscore>2</modscore>
	<htmltext>Obviously, the flute was burried by the flood. Because like dinosaurs, flutes were put there by the devil to fool us. Thus the phrase "devil music."</htmltext>
<tokenext>Obviously , the flute was burried by the flood .
Because like dinosaurs , flutes were put there by the devil to fool us .
Thus the phrase " devil music .
"</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Obviously, the flute was burried by the flood.
Because like dinosaurs, flutes were put there by the devil to fool us.
Thus the phrase "devil music.
"</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456405</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456737</id>
	<title>How can this be?</title>
	<author>lordvalrole</author>
	<datestamp>1245873840000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Redundant</modclass>
	<modscore>-1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Humans weren't here 35,000 years ago.  It was only 6,000 years ago. We could not have possibly enjoyed music 35,000 years ago. =)<nobr> <wbr></nobr>/end sarcasm</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Humans were n't here 35,000 years ago .
It was only 6,000 years ago .
We could not have possibly enjoyed music 35,000 years ago .
= ) /end sarcasm</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Humans weren't here 35,000 years ago.
It was only 6,000 years ago.
We could not have possibly enjoyed music 35,000 years ago.
=) /end sarcasm</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456485</id>
	<title>Is it april 1st again already?</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245872820000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Troll</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext>This really sounds like an april fools joke.

If it's accurate, it's interesting,  because there were also painting tools and a "stunning" carved female figurine.

So this place was either an arts university, or a nightclub.  Probably a nightclub, since I don't think they had McDonalds back then to hire arts graduates.</htmltext>
<tokenext>This really sounds like an april fools joke .
If it 's accurate , it 's interesting , because there were also painting tools and a " stunning " carved female figurine .
So this place was either an arts university , or a nightclub .
Probably a nightclub , since I do n't think they had McDonalds back then to hire arts graduates .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>This really sounds like an april fools joke.
If it's accurate, it's interesting,  because there were also painting tools and a "stunning" carved female figurine.
So this place was either an arts university, or a nightclub.
Probably a nightclub, since I don't think they had McDonalds back then to hire arts graduates.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457697</id>
	<title>Re:Complex vs Simple.</title>
	<author>geekoid</author>
	<datestamp>1245834360000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man.</p><p>No, thye did not.</p><p>"..., a significant \% of the population will be dead within 4 weeks."<br>which has nothing to do with intelligence.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man.No , thye did not .
" ... , a significant \ % of the population will be dead within 4 weeks .
" which has nothing to do with intelligence .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man.No, thye did not.
"..., a significant \% of the population will be dead within 4 weeks.
"which has nothing to do with intelligence.</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28459659</id>
	<title>We need a flute recital.</title>
	<author>Drone69</author>
	<datestamp>1245841920000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext>Mick Jagger, world's oldest musician, plays the world's oldest flute in a one-night only event from Carnegie Hall.</htmltext>
<tokenext>Mick Jagger , world 's oldest musician , plays the world 's oldest flute in a one-night only event from Carnegie Hall .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Mick Jagger, world's oldest musician, plays the world's oldest flute in a one-night only event from Carnegie Hall.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28588105</id>
	<title>Re:I'm Trying to Get Back to My Roots</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1246827180000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext><blockquote><div><p>anti-Cro Magnum themes</p></div></blockquote><p>Epic fail.</p></div>
	</htmltext>
<tokenext>anti-Cro Magnum themesEpic fail .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>anti-Cro Magnum themesEpic fail.
	</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456553</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456643</id>
	<title>Still not the oldest</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245873360000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Skin flutes are much older.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Skin flutes are much older .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Skin flutes are much older.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456689</id>
	<title>Cave Geeks?</title>
	<author>filesiteguy</author>
	<datestamp>1245873540000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Funny</modclass>
	<modscore>2</modscore>
	<htmltext>So, does this mean that the term "band geek" was discovered 35,000 years ago?<br><br>I wonder if they wore underwear so that Ogg could give the owner of this flute a wedgie.</htmltext>
<tokenext>So , does this mean that the term " band geek " was discovered 35,000 years ago ? I wonder if they wore underwear so that Ogg could give the owner of this flute a wedgie .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>So, does this mean that the term "band geek" was discovered 35,000 years ago?I wonder if they wore underwear so that Ogg could give the owner of this flute a wedgie.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458599</id>
	<title>I CLAIM COPYRIHGT BY ANSESTRY</title>
	<author>CHRONOSS2008</author>
	<datestamp>1245837540000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>-1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>haha ugh ugh hoo hoo. YEs thats right the new RIAA law means that ALL music now is pwned by me cause forever copyright back to when even it was created as htis is MY FLUTE you all owe me 99999999999999999$$$$$$$$</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>haha ugh ugh hoo hoo .
YEs thats right the new RIAA law means that ALL music now is pwned by me cause forever copyright back to when even it was created as htis is MY FLUTE you all owe me 99999999999999999 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $</tokentext>
<sentencetext>haha ugh ugh hoo hoo.
YEs thats right the new RIAA law means that ALL music now is pwned by me cause forever copyright back to when even it was created as htis is MY FLUTE you all owe me 99999999999999999$$$$$$$$</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456405</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456759</id>
	<title>Needs some inner light ...</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245873960000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Funny</modclass>
	<modscore>2</modscore>
	<htmltext>
Psssft.   Get back to me when the grad student who dug it out collapses into a coma and lives a lifetime as a paleolithic hunter, then wakes up and can play some good mammoth hunting songs<nobr> <wbr></nobr>...</htmltext>
<tokenext>Psssft .
Get back to me when the grad student who dug it out collapses into a coma and lives a lifetime as a paleolithic hunter , then wakes up and can play some good mammoth hunting songs .. .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>
Psssft.
Get back to me when the grad student who dug it out collapses into a coma and lives a lifetime as a paleolithic hunter, then wakes up and can play some good mammoth hunting songs ...</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28459519</id>
	<title>Picard</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245841260000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Captain Picard's flute was older, no?</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Captain Picard 's flute was older , no ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Captain Picard's flute was older, no?</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433</id>
	<title>This one time</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245872640000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Funny</modclass>
	<modscore>5</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>This one time, 35,000 years ago at band camp...</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>This one time , 35,000 years ago at band camp.. .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>This one time, 35,000 years ago at band camp...</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461635</id>
	<title>Re:Interesting!</title>
	<author>bcrowell</author>
	<datestamp>1245854340000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><blockquote><div><p>Pity TFA lacks more detail about the tonality. It would be interesting to know what notes it could produce, and what intervals, possibly indicating whether they leaned to minor or major scale for example..</p></div>
</blockquote><p>
The major/minor system is less than a thousand years old, and only occurs in Western music.
</p></div>
	</htmltext>
<tokenext>Pity TFA lacks more detail about the tonality .
It would be interesting to know what notes it could produce , and what intervals , possibly indicating whether they leaned to minor or major scale for example. . The major/minor system is less than a thousand years old , and only occurs in Western music .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Pity TFA lacks more detail about the tonality.
It would be interesting to know what notes it could produce, and what intervals, possibly indicating whether they leaned to minor or major scale for example..

The major/minor system is less than a thousand years old, and only occurs in Western music.

	</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457191</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28463367</id>
	<title>Re:Complex vs Simple.</title>
	<author>harl</author>
	<datestamp>1245871320000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p><div class="quote"><p>Consider this: prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man.  If all electrical devices stop working tomorrow, a significant \% of the population will be dead within 4 weeks.</p></div><p>You're confusing knowledge and intelligence.</p><p>We're all capable of learning how to live off the land.  We've simply never learned how due to lack of need.</p></div>
	</htmltext>
<tokenext>Consider this : prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man .
If all electrical devices stop working tomorrow , a significant \ % of the population will be dead within 4 weeks.You 're confusing knowledge and intelligence.We 're all capable of learning how to live off the land .
We 've simply never learned how due to lack of need .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Consider this: prehistoric man had to be MORE intelligent to survive then modern man.
If all electrical devices stop working tomorrow, a significant \% of the population will be dead within 4 weeks.You're confusing knowledge and intelligence.We're all capable of learning how to live off the land.
We've simply never learned how due to lack of need.
	</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28468961</id>
	<title>TNG: The Inner light</title>
	<author>ext42fs</author>
	<datestamp>1245955500000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext>Can't suppress remembering Star Trek Next Generation episode "The Inner Light".
<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The\_Inner\_Light\_(TNG\_episode)" title="wikipedia.org" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The\_Inner\_Light\_(TNG\_episode)</a> [wikipedia.org]</htmltext>
<tokenext>Ca n't suppress remembering Star Trek Next Generation episode " The Inner Light " .
http : //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The \ _Inner \ _Light \ _ ( TNG \ _episode ) [ wikipedia.org ]</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Can't suppress remembering Star Trek Next Generation episode "The Inner Light".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The\_Inner\_Light\_(TNG\_episode) [wikipedia.org]</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456985</id>
	<title>Re:This one time</title>
	<author>dkleinsc</author>
	<datestamp>1245874860000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Informativ</modclass>
	<modscore>2</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Come on, this far in and there have been absolutely know "playing the bone flute" jokes?</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Come on , this far in and there have been absolutely know " playing the bone flute " jokes ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Come on, this far in and there have been absolutely know "playing the bone flute" jokes?</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458807</id>
	<title>Re:Interesting!</title>
	<author>u38cg</author>
	<datestamp>1245838380000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Interestin</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext>Not quite sure why you got a funny...but never mind.  Listening to the sound sample on the NYT site (linked in the comments somewhere above), the player pulled a straight major pentatonic scale out of it.  Interestingly, the previously oldest known woodwind instrument (unearthed somewhere near Ur and c.5000 years old was also apparently pentatonic.  Given the care that went into constructing these flute, I don't think that's an accident.</htmltext>
<tokenext>Not quite sure why you got a funny...but never mind .
Listening to the sound sample on the NYT site ( linked in the comments somewhere above ) , the player pulled a straight major pentatonic scale out of it .
Interestingly , the previously oldest known woodwind instrument ( unearthed somewhere near Ur and c.5000 years old was also apparently pentatonic .
Given the care that went into constructing these flute , I do n't think that 's an accident .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Not quite sure why you got a funny...but never mind.
Listening to the sound sample on the NYT site (linked in the comments somewhere above), the player pulled a straight major pentatonic scale out of it.
Interestingly, the previously oldest known woodwind instrument (unearthed somewhere near Ur and c.5000 years old was also apparently pentatonic.
Given the care that went into constructing these flute, I don't think that's an accident.</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457191</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28472851</id>
	<title>An interesting fact</title>
	<author>alexo</author>
	<datestamp>1245926220000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>It shows that Homo Sapiens created music for over 33K years before the advent of copyrights.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>It shows that Homo Sapiens created music for over 33K years before the advent of copyrights .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>It shows that Homo Sapiens created music for over 33K years before the advent of copyrights.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457655</id>
	<title>South Germany = Cradle of civilization?</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245834180000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Interestin</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>In 2006, archaeologists in south Germany found the first art object known to man:</p><p>http://www.visual-arts-cork.com/prehistoric/ivory-carvings-swabian-jura.htm</p><p>Now the oldest instrument was found, also in south Germany.</p><p>I guess this means civilization originated in <i>Deutshland</i>.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>In 2006 , archaeologists in south Germany found the first art object known to man : http : //www.visual-arts-cork.com/prehistoric/ivory-carvings-swabian-jura.htmNow the oldest instrument was found , also in south Germany.I guess this means civilization originated in Deutshland .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>In 2006, archaeologists in south Germany found the first art object known to man:http://www.visual-arts-cork.com/prehistoric/ivory-carvings-swabian-jura.htmNow the oldest instrument was found, also in south Germany.I guess this means civilization originated in Deutshland.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458027</id>
	<title>I'd like some hot chicks (and other flute jokes)</title>
	<author>geekoid</author>
	<datestamp>1245835740000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Funny</modclass>
	<modscore>4</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>to date my bone flute.<br>*giggity*</p><p>How did they know it was a flute? There were carvings on the wall from people whining they could ahve done it better/</p><p>How did they get two flutes in tune? they bashed the skull in of one of the bone flautists.</p><p>Why did the neanderthal go extinct? to get away from the flute recital.</p><p>How many bone Flautists did it taker to start a fire? 2 one to do it and another to push them into the fire.</p><p>What do you call a flute that's been buried for 35000 years? A good start.</p><p>2 flutists ride a mammoth over a cliff, what's the tragedy? you can fit 4 flutists on a mammoth.</p><p>I can go on, but unlike a flautists I know when to stop.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>to date my bone flute .
* giggity * How did they know it was a flute ?
There were carvings on the wall from people whining they could ahve done it better/How did they get two flutes in tune ?
they bashed the skull in of one of the bone flautists.Why did the neanderthal go extinct ?
to get away from the flute recital.How many bone Flautists did it taker to start a fire ?
2 one to do it and another to push them into the fire.What do you call a flute that 's been buried for 35000 years ?
A good start.2 flutists ride a mammoth over a cliff , what 's the tragedy ?
you can fit 4 flutists on a mammoth.I can go on , but unlike a flautists I know when to stop .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>to date my bone flute.
*giggity*How did they know it was a flute?
There were carvings on the wall from people whining they could ahve done it better/How did they get two flutes in tune?
they bashed the skull in of one of the bone flautists.Why did the neanderthal go extinct?
to get away from the flute recital.How many bone Flautists did it taker to start a fire?
2 one to do it and another to push them into the fire.What do you call a flute that's been buried for 35000 years?
A good start.2 flutists ride a mammoth over a cliff, what's the tragedy?
you can fit 4 flutists on a mammoth.I can go on, but unlike a flautists I know when to stop.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458085</id>
	<title>Re:This one time</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245835920000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext>ROTFL</htmltext>
<tokenext>ROTFL</tokentext>
<sentencetext>ROTFL</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457721</id>
	<title>Re:Complex vs Simple.</title>
	<author>Ian Alexander</author>
	<datestamp>1245834480000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext>I think there's a difference in the level of thinking required to realize that you can bang two sticks together and seeking out a hollow stick of just the right dimensions and cutting holes at the appropriate intervals such that when you force air through it you can control the kind of sound it makes.<br> <br>Not that that means you're less intelligent for being happy with banging two sticks together (that's about the degree of musical aptitude I possess), but one obviously takes a little more forethought to produce. This just goes to show that the gulf between "primitive" humanity and "modern" humanity really ain't so great as we once thought. You're right, though- this probably wouldn't so much shed light on the <i>origins</i> of music so much as it fills in details of its early days. I believe musical instruments- including flutes- have been found at Neanderthal sites as well, and earlier than this one.</htmltext>
<tokenext>I think there 's a difference in the level of thinking required to realize that you can bang two sticks together and seeking out a hollow stick of just the right dimensions and cutting holes at the appropriate intervals such that when you force air through it you can control the kind of sound it makes .
Not that that means you 're less intelligent for being happy with banging two sticks together ( that 's about the degree of musical aptitude I possess ) , but one obviously takes a little more forethought to produce .
This just goes to show that the gulf between " primitive " humanity and " modern " humanity really ai n't so great as we once thought .
You 're right , though- this probably would n't so much shed light on the origins of music so much as it fills in details of its early days .
I believe musical instruments- including flutes- have been found at Neanderthal sites as well , and earlier than this one .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>I think there's a difference in the level of thinking required to realize that you can bang two sticks together and seeking out a hollow stick of just the right dimensions and cutting holes at the appropriate intervals such that when you force air through it you can control the kind of sound it makes.
Not that that means you're less intelligent for being happy with banging two sticks together (that's about the degree of musical aptitude I possess), but one obviously takes a little more forethought to produce.
This just goes to show that the gulf between "primitive" humanity and "modern" humanity really ain't so great as we once thought.
You're right, though- this probably wouldn't so much shed light on the origins of music so much as it fills in details of its early days.
I believe musical instruments- including flutes- have been found at Neanderthal sites as well, and earlier than this one.</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456409</id>
	<title>Flute</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245872580000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Troll</modclass>
	<modscore>-1</modscore>
	<htmltext>That headline is not complete.  It should say:
<br> <br>
<b>35,000-year-old Flute Is Oldest Musical Instrument Ever Found, Slashdotters Highly Disappointed Flute Is Not Made of Skin.</b>
<br> <br>
By the way, FIRST POST!!</htmltext>
<tokenext>That headline is not complete .
It should say : 35,000-year-old Flute Is Oldest Musical Instrument Ever Found , Slashdotters Highly Disappointed Flute Is Not Made of Skin .
By the way , FIRST POST !
!</tokentext>
<sentencetext>That headline is not complete.
It should say:
 
35,000-year-old Flute Is Oldest Musical Instrument Ever Found, Slashdotters Highly Disappointed Flute Is Not Made of Skin.
By the way, FIRST POST!
!</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456553</id>
	<title>I'm Trying to Get Back to My Roots</title>
	<author>eldavojohn</author>
	<datestamp>1245873000000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext>Like Eric Clapton <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Me\_and\_Mr.\_Johnson" title="wikipedia.org" rel="nofollow">releasing an album paying homage to the great blues guitarist Robert Johnson</a> [wikipedia.org], my next album will be concentrating on my roots and be recorded entirely on thirty five thousand year old flutes using only the recording technology they had back then<nobr> <wbr></nobr>... I predict this will appeal more to the older crowd and while a lot of the themes of the songs have anti-Cro Magnum themes, I think this sort of retro music is long overdue.</htmltext>
<tokenext>Like Eric Clapton releasing an album paying homage to the great blues guitarist Robert Johnson [ wikipedia.org ] , my next album will be concentrating on my roots and be recorded entirely on thirty five thousand year old flutes using only the recording technology they had back then ... I predict this will appeal more to the older crowd and while a lot of the themes of the songs have anti-Cro Magnum themes , I think this sort of retro music is long overdue .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Like Eric Clapton releasing an album paying homage to the great blues guitarist Robert Johnson [wikipedia.org], my next album will be concentrating on my roots and be recorded entirely on thirty five thousand year old flutes using only the recording technology they had back then ... I predict this will appeal more to the older crowd and while a lot of the themes of the songs have anti-Cro Magnum themes, I think this sort of retro music is long overdue.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28459743</id>
	<title>Re:Cave Geeks?</title>
	<author>Opportunist</author>
	<datestamp>1245842340000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Given his name, and the rather rought times back then, he's probably been stuffed into a container with a few parts of him missing.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Given his name , and the rather rought times back then , he 's probably been stuffed into a container with a few parts of him missing .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Given his name, and the rather rought times back then, he's probably been stuffed into a container with a few parts of him missing.</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456689</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456405</id>
	<title>My Heavens!</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245872580000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Funny</modclass>
	<modscore>4</modscore>
	<htmltext>That flute is -29,000 years old!</htmltext>
<tokenext>That flute is -29,000 years old !</tokentext>
<sentencetext>That flute is -29,000 years old!</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461905</id>
	<title>I think you mean</title>
	<author>geekoid</author>
	<datestamp>1245856560000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>This one time, 35,000 years ago at band cave...</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>This one time , 35,000 years ago at band cave.. .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>This one time, 35,000 years ago at band cave...</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457191</id>
	<title>Re:Interesting!</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245875640000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Interestin</modclass>
	<modscore>4</modscore>
	<htmltext>Pity TFA lacks more detail about the tonality. It would be interesting to know what notes it could produce, and what intervals, possibly indicating  whether they leaned to minor or major scale for example..</htmltext>
<tokenext>Pity TFA lacks more detail about the tonality .
It would be interesting to know what notes it could produce , and what intervals , possibly indicating whether they leaned to minor or major scale for example. .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Pity TFA lacks more detail about the tonality.
It would be interesting to know what notes it could produce, and what intervals, possibly indicating  whether they leaned to minor or major scale for example..</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456415</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456831</id>
	<title>Alert me!</title>
	<author>GooDieZ</author>
	<datestamp>1245874260000</datestamp>
	<modclass>Troll</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>...when they discover that this stuff is GPL... RIAA will be on the case soon<nobr> <wbr></nobr>:D</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>...when they discover that this stuff is GPL... RIAA will be on the case soon : D</tokentext>
<sentencetext>...when they discover that this stuff is GPL... RIAA will be on the case soon :D</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457201</id>
	<title>Journalism sucks</title>
	<author>FeatherBoa</author>
	<datestamp>1245875700000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>There is a serious problem with journalism here.  From TFA,</p><p><i>Nearly 22 centimetres (8.7 inches) long and 2.2 centimetres (one inch) in diameter</i></p><p>The photograph clearly shows that the object in question is not more than 2/3 the diameter of the person's finger.  This is NOT 2.2cm -- it is probably around 10mm to 12mm.  So how much of ANY of the rest of the info in this article accurate?</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>There is a serious problem with journalism here .
From TFA,Nearly 22 centimetres ( 8.7 inches ) long and 2.2 centimetres ( one inch ) in diameterThe photograph clearly shows that the object in question is not more than 2/3 the diameter of the person 's finger .
This is NOT 2.2cm -- it is probably around 10mm to 12mm .
So how much of ANY of the rest of the info in this article accurate ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>There is a serious problem with journalism here.
From TFA,Nearly 22 centimetres (8.7 inches) long and 2.2 centimetres (one inch) in diameterThe photograph clearly shows that the object in question is not more than 2/3 the diameter of the person's finger.
This is NOT 2.2cm -- it is probably around 10mm to 12mm.
So how much of ANY of the rest of the info in this article accurate?</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461913</id>
	<title>Re:This one time</title>
	<author>geekoid</author>
	<datestamp>1245856620000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>Sorry I was busy fluting my playing bone.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>Sorry I was busy fluting my playing bone .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Sorry I was busy fluting my playing bone.</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456985</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456783</id>
	<title>Yo Mama is soooo old...</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245874020000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>There is a Skin flute older than a Vulture Bone flute joke in there somewhere...</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>There is a Skin flute older than a Vulture Bone flute joke in there somewhere.. .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>There is a Skin flute older than a Vulture Bone flute joke in there somewhere...</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457511</id>
	<title>Inner Light...</title>
	<author>Palshife</author>
	<datestamp>1245876900000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>So was the discoverer forced to live the life of one of the villagers in a simulation, learning the way of their culture and becoming richer for the experience?</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>So was the discoverer forced to live the life of one of the villagers in a simulation , learning the way of their culture and becoming richer for the experience ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>So was the discoverer forced to live the life of one of the villagers in a simulation, learning the way of their culture and becoming richer for the experience?</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456795</id>
	<title>That's neat and all, but I'd like to see...</title>
	<author>TigerPlish</author>
	<datestamp>1245874080000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>That flute is neat, and looks well made (chamfered holes?!)</p><p>But what I'd love to see even more is a piece of 35,000 year old sheet music.  That way, we'd know what they grooved to back when the earth was still cooling, and people walked to school uphill both ways in the snow, dontchaknow.</p><p>Seriously.  I wanna see the music.</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>That flute is neat , and looks well made ( chamfered holes ? !
) But what I 'd love to see even more is a piece of 35,000 year old sheet music .
That way , we 'd know what they grooved to back when the earth was still cooling , and people walked to school uphill both ways in the snow , dontchaknow.Seriously .
I wan na see the music .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>That flute is neat, and looks well made (chamfered holes?!
)But what I'd love to see even more is a piece of 35,000 year old sheet music.
That way, we'd know what they grooved to back when the earth was still cooling, and people walked to school uphill both ways in the snow, dontchaknow.Seriously.
I wanna see the music.</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28463205</id>
	<title>Why not 1000 years back?</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245869340000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext>Couldn't it happen that the "bone" was found 1000 years ago and the people at that time carved a flute out of it?</htmltext>
<tokenext>Could n't it happen that the " bone " was found 1000 years ago and the people at that time carved a flute out of it ?</tokentext>
<sentencetext>Couldn't it happen that the "bone" was found 1000 years ago and the people at that time carved a flute out of it?</sentencetext>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457367</id>
	<title>Re:Needs some inner light ...</title>
	<author>Anonymous</author>
	<datestamp>1245876300000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>0</modscore>
	<htmltext><p>I'd mark that ST:TNG reference as a "nice try, but could do better".</p></htmltext>
<tokenext>I 'd mark that ST : TNG reference as a " nice try , but could do better " .</tokentext>
<sentencetext>I'd mark that ST:TNG reference as a "nice try, but could do better".</sentencetext>
	<parent>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456759</parent>
</comment>
<comment>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28463905</id>
	<title>Interesting what ancient flutes were made from..</title>
	<author>xanadu113</author>
	<datestamp>1245921240000</datestamp>
	<modclass>None</modclass>
	<modscore>1</modscore>
	<htmltext>It's interesting what ancient flutes were made from...<br>
<br>
Now adays people are making them out of bamboo:<br>
<br>
<a href="http://www.thomasrichardsonmusic.com/" title="thomasrich...nmusic.com" rel="nofollow">http://www.thomasrichardsonmusic.com</a> [thomasrich...nmusic.com]</htmltext>
<tokenext>It 's interesting what ancient flutes were made from.. . Now adays people are making them out of bamboo : http : //www.thomasrichardsonmusic.com [ thomasrich...nmusic.com ]</tokentext>
<sentencetext>It's interesting what ancient flutes were made from...

Now adays people are making them out of bamboo:

http://www.thomasrichardsonmusic.com [thomasrich...nmusic.com]</sentencetext>
</comment>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_9</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457721
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_6</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458261
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_10</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461905
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_3</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458807
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457191
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456415
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_11</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28588105
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456553
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_7</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457697
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_0</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461913
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456985
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_1</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461635
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457191
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456415
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_12</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28463367
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_5</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458599
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456405
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_4</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456601
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456405
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_13</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28459743
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456689
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_8</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458085
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433
</commentlist>
</thread>
<thread>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#thread_09_06_24_1831232_2</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457367
http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456759
</commentlist>
</thread>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.5</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456433
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458085
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456985
--http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461913
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461905
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.14</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456485
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.3</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458027
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.12</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456737
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.9</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456405
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456601
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458599
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.7</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456785
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.4</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456415
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457191
--http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28461635
--http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458807
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.2</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456625
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.13</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456759
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457367
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.1</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456661
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28463367
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28458261
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457697
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457721
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.11</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456689
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28459743
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.10</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456409
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.8</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28457201
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.6</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28464423
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.15</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456795
</commentlist>
</conversation>
<conversation>
	<id>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#conversation09_06_24_1831232.0</id>
	<commentlist>http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28456553
-http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/ConversationInstances.owl#comment09_06_24_1831232.28588105
</commentlist>
</conversation>
