Supervisor: Stefano Maffulli <>
Announced end of poll: September 4th 2011, 12:00pm CDT
Actual time poll closed:
Private poll (180 authorized voters)
Actual votes cast: 101
Number of winning choices:
Condorcet completion rule:    (What is this?)
Schulze/Beatpath/CSSD
CIVS Ranked Pairs
MAM
Condorcet-IRV

Poll description

OpenStack Project Policy Board Elections

The Nomination Process will run from August 10 – 24 at Noon CDT.

Result

1. Ewan Mellor  (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices)
2. Paul Voccio  loses to Ewan Mellor by 46–40
3. Tied:
Monty Taylor  loses to Ewan Mellor by 47–40, loses to Paul Voccio by 45–38
Josh Kearney  loses to Ewan Mellor by 54–29, loses to Paul Voccio by 48–26
5. Soren Hansen  loses to Ewan Mellor by 52–35, loses to Josh Kearney by 44–42
6. Brian Lamar  loses to Ewan Mellor by 58–26, loses to Soren Hansen by 46–43
7. Rick Clark  loses to Ewan Mellor by 53–40, loses to Brian Lamar by 46–44
8. Christopher MacGown  loses to Ewan Mellor by 45–35, loses to Rick Clark by 48–40
9. Chuck Thier  loses to Ewan Mellor by 55–28, loses to Christopher MacGown by 38–33
10. Joe Arnold  loses to Ewan Mellor by 56–22, loses to Chuck Thier by 41–28
11. Joe Heck  loses to Ewan Mellor by 54–26, loses to Joe Arnold by 32–29
12. Rob Hirschfeld  loses to Ewan Mellor by 63–15, loses to Joe Heck by 35–30
13. Tied:
Jason Cannavale  loses to Ewan Mellor by 58–18, loses to Rob Hirschfeld by 33–27
Blake Yeager  loses to Ewan Mellor by 62–22, loses to Rob Hirschfeld by 43–27

For simplicity, some details of the poll result are not shown.  

Result details

  1234567891011121314
1. Ewan Mellor   -46 47 54 52 58 53 45 55 56 54 63 58 62
2. Paul Voccio   40 -45 48 51 53 53 41 47 46 49 56 55 60
3. Monty Taylor   40 38 -41 40 50 47 49 39 51 45 50 52 57
4. Josh Kearney   29 26 40 -44 53 51 37 41 39 42 50 47 53
5. Soren Hansen   35 38 41 42 -46 43 49 42 53 49 48 46 53
6. Brian Lamar   26 21 29 18 43 -46 31 39 35 31 36 36 42
7. Rick Clark   40 41 38 41 37 44 -48 43 50 47 46 46 47
8. Christopher MacGown   35 29 31 29 34 39 40 -38 43 35 46 47 46
9. Chuck Thier   28 29 39 31 34 36 42 33 -41 38 43 43 42
10. Joe Arnold   22 26 25 29 28 32 33 22 28 -32 32 30 36
11. Joe Heck   26 25 29 29 34 31 37 27 32 29 -35 33 37
12. Rob Hirschfeld   15 19 28 22 34 32 41 24 29 27 30 -33 43
13. Jason Cannavale   18 14 24 22 37 23 41 19 27 27 23 27 -30
14. Blake Yeager   22 16 25 21 34 22 38 24 31 28 26 27 30 -

Ballot reporting was not enabled for this poll.

The following matrix shows the strength of the strongest beatpath connecting each pair of choices. Choice 1 is ranked above choice 2 if there is a stronger beatpath leading from 1 to 2 than any leading from 2 to 1.

  1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.
1. Ewan Mellor   -46–40 47–40 54–29 52–35 58–26 53–40 49–34 55–28 56–22 54–26 63–15 58–18 62–22
2. Paul Voccio   . -45–38 48–26 51–38 53–21 53–41 49–34 47–29 51–38 49–25 56–19 55–14 60–16
3. Monty Taylor   . . -41–40 41–40 50–29 47–38 49–31 43–42 51–25 47–38 50–28 52–24 57–25
4. Josh Kearney   . . 41–40 -44–42 53–18 51–41 48–40 43–42 50–33 47–37 50–22 47–19 53–21
5. Soren Hansen   . . 41–40 41–40 -46–43 46–44 49–34 43–42 53–28 49–34 48–34 47–19 53–34
6. Brian Lamar   . . . . . -46–44 46–44 43–42 46–44 46–44 46–44 46–44 46–44
7. Rick Clark   . . . . . 39–31 -48–40 43–42 50–33 47–37 46–24 47–19 47–38
8. Christopher MacGown   . . . . . 39–31 39–31 -39–31 43–22 39–31 46–24 47–19 46–24
9. Chuck Thier   . . . . . . . . -41–28 38–32 43–29 43–27 43–29
10. Joe Arnold   . . . . . . . . . -32–29 32–27 32–27 36–28
11. Joe Heck   . . . . . . . . . . -35–30 33–23 37–26
12. Rob Hirschfeld   . . . . . . . . . . . -33–27 43–27
13. Jason Cannavale   . . . . . . . . . . . . -.
14. Blake Yeager   . . . . . . . . . . . . . -