Supervisor: Raffaella Traniello ()
Announced end of poll: 31 December 2008 at 00:01 UTC
Actual time poll closed: Wed Dec 31 19:00:14 2008
Private poll (668 authorized voters)
Actual votes cast: 127
Number of winning choices:
Condorcet completion rule: Beatpath/Schulze/CSSD    CIVS Ranked Pairs    MAM Condorcet-IRV    (What is this?) 

Poll description

Lumiera, the new emerging NLE for Linux, is looking for a logo.
A Logo Contest has been organized.
More than 100 logo concepts have been submitted, discussed and improved by the community.
21 logos have been selected for the vote, following the preferences expressed by the community.

Now it's time for you to judge them all.

Please, look carefully at every logo on the Selection page.
For each logo you can view more images and variations for different purposes by clicking on the thumbnail.
The list of candidates to be ranked has no images. Logos are represented by a number, a title and the creator's name.
Rank each logo with a number. Number 1 is for the best ones.

Thanks for your contribution!

Ranking of the choices

1. #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii  (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices)
2. #108 HUMMINGBIRD by Alexis Sánchez  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 47–36
3. #32 LAMP by Bull[X]  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 41–34, loses to #108 HUMMINGBIRD by Alexis Sánchez by 44–39
4. #48 HANDS by Joaquín Herrera Goás  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 41–34, loses to #32 LAMP by Bull[X] by 41–30
5. #24 LUMIERE BROTHERS by Marci  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 47–34, loses to #48 HANDS by Joaquín Herrera Goás by 42–34
6. #98 RAINBOW FLAME by Sam  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 41–26, loses to #24 LUMIERE BROTHERS by Marci by 40–34
7. #47 BROWN PROJECTOR by Mendoza  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 45–28, loses to #24 LUMIERE BROTHERS by Marci by 41–32
8. #69 MOVING LOGO by Ariane Stolfi  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 47–26, loses to #98 RAINBOW FLAME by Sam by 35–30
9. #76 CAMERAMAN by Claudio Castelli  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 43–26, loses to #69 MOVING LOGO by Ariane Stolfi by 36–30
10. #97 SUN by The Furlinator  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 45–27, loses to #76 CAMERAMAN by Claudio Castelli by 35–34
11. #81 FILMWAVE by Richard Querin  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 48–18, loses to #97 SUN by The Furlinator by 35–27
12. #18 LUM()ERA by ?  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 50–20, loses to #81 FILMWAVE by Richard Querin by 33–28
13. #101 RGB LEAVES by Velmont  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 51–23, loses to #18 LUM()ERA by ? by 34–30
14. #22 THREE DOTS E by Marci  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 50–26, loses to #101 RGB LEAVES by Velmont by 32–29
15. #102 MOTH by Arimal  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 55–19, loses to #101 RGB LEAVES by Velmont by 33–31
16. #88 CANDLE by Carlos Tobias (CTOBIAS)  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 50–19, loses to #102 MOTH by Arimal by 31–27
17. Tied:
#6 INTEGRATION by Leandro Ribeiro  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 52–18, loses to #88 CANDLE by Carlos Tobias (CTOBIAS) by 31–23
#23 RGB CIRCLES by mexicorara  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 54–14, loses to #88 CANDLE by Carlos Tobias (CTOBIAS) by 30–22
19. #83 RGB M by juarnez  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 51–15, loses to #6 INTEGRATION by Leandro Ribeiro by 25–24
20. #89 GOLDEN FILM by Thorsten Wilms (thorwil)  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 55–11, loses to #83 RGB M by juarnez by 28–17
21. #46 EARLY HORSE by pineconecs  loses to #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii by 56–10, loses to #89 GOLDEN FILM by Thorsten Wilms (thorwil) by 24–22

For simplicity, some details of the poll result are not shown.

Result details

  1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.15.16.17.18.19.20.21.
1. #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii   -47 41 41 47 41 45 47 43 45 48 50 51 50 55 50 52 54 51 55 56
2. #108 HUMMINGBIRD by Alexis Sánchez   36 -44 44 46 45 51 49 52 45 53 52 52 52 57 53 56 58 55 58 59
3. #32 LAMP by Bull[X]   34 39 -41 44 35 41 44 45 43 47 48 42 46 47 44 54 53 49 55 51
4. #48 HANDS by Joaquín Herrera Goás   34 37 30 -42 43 48 41 41 42 45 46 47 45 45 44 47 52 50 49 48
5. #24 LUMIERE BROTHERS by Marci   34 36 30 34 -40 41 37 40 36 42 43 43 42 48 43 46 45 47 53 47
6. #98 RAINBOW FLAME by Sam   26 31 29 28 34 -32 35 36 30 33 39 35 38 35 36 41 40 37 42 45
7. #47 BROWN PROJECTOR by Mendoza   28 28 29 21 32 33 -29 35 35 33 36 35 35 37 36 41 38 39 42 42
8. #69 MOVING LOGO by Ariane Stolfi   26 28 26 28 33 30 33 -36 30 32 33 34 32 38 37 36 36 38 45 41
9. #76 CAMERAMAN by Claudio Castelli   26 27 25 28 30 29 28 30 -35 32 33 36 34 35 36 37 39 34 38 36
10. #97 SUN by The Furlinator   27 34 26 29 36 33 34 34 34 -35 38 36 40 39 38 44 44 42 46 43
11. #81 FILMWAVE by Richard Querin   18 19 21 25 27 24 30 26 30 27 -33 29 33 36 30 35 34 32 40 37
12. #18 LUM()ERA by ?   20 24 17 22 25 25 28 30 27 24 28 -34 28 35 30 33 32 33 34 34
13. #101 RGB LEAVES by Velmont   23 21 26 25 32 28 27 28 30 27 30 30 -32 33 33 35 33 31 40 39
14. #22 THREE DOTS E by Marci   26 28 20 27 25 30 27 31 30 25 31 31 29 -34 30 38 38 32 41 36
15. #102 MOTH by Arimal   19 19 20 22 27 29 31 29 30 27 29 28 31 34 -31 37 36 31 40 35
16. #88 CANDLE by Carlos Tobias (CTOBIAS)   19 22 19 21 24 24 23 22 24 20 24 26 25 25 27 -31 30 26 33 35
17. #6 INTEGRATION by Leandro Ribeiro   18 18 15 22 20 21 20 22 24 22 26 27 24 20 24 23 -26 25 28 29
18. #23 RGB CIRCLES by mexicorara   14 18 14 16 23 22 18 20 22 20 23 25 27 20 27 22 26 -24 31 29
19. #83 RGB M by juarnez   15 17 15 16 16 16 18 19 20 17 22 20 22 25 24 22 24 23 -28 27
20. #89 GOLDEN FILM by Thorsten Wilms (thorwil)   11 13 7 14 14 13 16 13 18 12 14 17 15 13 17 13 22 18 17 -24
21. #46 EARLY HORSE by pineconecs   10 14 12 12 12 15 15 16 15 16 18 17 19 18 18 15 20 21 19 22 -

Ballot reporting was not enabled for this poll.

The following matrix shows the strength of the strongest beatpath connecting each pair of choices. Choice 1 is ranked above choice 2 if there is a stronger beatpath leading from 1 to 2 than any leading from 2 to 1.

  1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.15.16.17.18.19.20.21.
1. #96 PEEPING FRAME by anamii   -47–36 44–39 44–37 47–34 45–31 47–36 47–26 47–36 45–27 48–18 50–20 51–23 50–26 55–19 50–19 52–18 54–14 51–15 55–11 56–10
2. #108 HUMMINGBIRD by Alexis Sánchez   . -44–39 44–37 46–36 45–31 51–28 49–28 52–27 45–34 53–19 52–24 52–21 52–28 57–19 53–22 56–18 58–18 55–17 58–13 59–14
3. #32 LAMP by Bull[X]   . . -41–30 44–30 41–30 41–29 44–26 45–25 43–26 47–21 48–17 43–32 46–20 47–20 44–19 54–15 53–14 49–15 55–7 51–12
4. #48 HANDS by Joaquín Herrera Goás   . . . -42–34 43–28 48–21 41–28 41–28 42–29 45–25 46–22 47–25 45–27 45–22 44–21 47–22 52–16 50–16 49–14 48–12
5. #24 LUMIERE BROTHERS by Marci   . . . . -40–34 41–32 37–33 40–30 35–34 42–27 43–25 43–32 42–25 48–27 43–24 46–20 45–23 47–16 53–14 47–12
6. #98 RAINBOW FLAME by Sam   . . . . . -33–29 35–30 36–29 35–34 35–34 39–25 36–30 38–30 35–28 36–24 41–21 40–22 37–16 42–13 45–15
7. #47 BROWN PROJECTOR by Mendoza   . . . . . 33–30 -34–30 35–28 35–34 35–34 36–28 35–27 35–27 37–31 36–23 41–20 38–18 39–18 42–16 42–15
8. #69 MOVING LOGO by Ariane Stolfi   . . . . . 33–30 33–29 -36–30 35–34 35–34 35–34 36–30 35–34 38–29 37–22 37–24 36–20 38–19 45–13 41–16
9. #76 CAMERAMAN by Claudio Castelli   . . . . . 33–30 33–29 34–30 -35–34 35–34 35–34 36–30 35–34 35–30 36–24 37–24 39–22 35–34 38–18 36–15
10. #97 SUN by The Furlinator   . . . . . 33–30 33–29 34–30 34–30 -35–27 38–24 36–27 40–25 39–27 38–20 44–22 44–20 42–17 46–12 43–16
11. #81 FILMWAVE by Richard Querin   . . . . . . . . . . -33–28 33–28 33–31 36–29 33–28 36–29 36–29 33–28 40–14 37–18
12. #18 LUM()ERA by ?   . . . . . . . . . . 30–29 -34–30 32–29 35–28 33–25 35–28 35–28 33–20 35–28 35–28
13. #101 RGB LEAVES by Velmont   . . . . . . . . . . 30–29 31–28 -32–29 33–31 33–25 35–24 33–27 32–29 40–15 39–19
14. #22 THREE DOTS E by Marci   . . . . . . . . . . 30–29 31–28 31–28 -31–28 31–28 38–20 38–20 32–25 41–13 36–18
15. #102 MOTH by Arimal   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -31–27 37–24 36–27 31–24 40–17 35–18
16. #88 CANDLE by Carlos Tobias (CTOBIAS)   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -31–23 30–22 26–22 33–13 35–15
17. #6 INTEGRATION by Leandro Ribeiro   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -. 25–24 28–22 29–20
18. #23 RGB CIRCLES by mexicorara   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -24–23 31–18 29–21
19. #83 RGB M by juarnez   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -28–17 27–19
20. #89 GOLDEN FILM by Thorsten Wilms (thorwil)   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -24–22
21. #46 EARLY HORSE by pineconecs   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -