# Silent Tongue (1993)

### reviewed by
Dennis Schwartz

SILENT TONGUE (director/writer: Sam Shepard; cinematographer: Jack Conroy; editor: Bill Yahraus; cast: Richard Harris (Prescott Roe), Sheila Tousey (Awbonnie/Ghost), Alan Bates (Eamon McCree), River Phoenix (Talbot Roe), Dermot Mulroney (Reeves McCree), Jeri Arredondo (Velada McCree), Tantoo Cardinal (Silent Tongue); Runtime: 101; Canal Plus/Belbo/Alive Films; 1993)

    Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz

Playwright and actor, Sam Shepard, writes and directs a strangely intriguing art-house Western about the ill-fated clash between European and Native American cultures that came with Western expansion. It plays more like a theatrical ghost story or a Greek tragedy than a Western. It is set in 1873, in the plains of New Mexico, where a quack, alcoholic, cowardly, thickly Irish brogue-talking professor, Eamon McCree (Alan Bates), runs the Kickapoo Traveling Medicine Show, with his despondent son Reeves (Mulroney) as his assistant.

Eamon raped an Indian woman (Tantoo Cardinal), who was made mute by her Kiowa tribe and left alone in the wilderness. She gave birth to twin girls, Awbonnie (Sheila Tousey) and Velada (Jeri Arredondo). Out of a sense of guilt he marries her and raises the girls as his own, unaware of the avenging anger Silent Tongue had for him.

When Prescott Roe (Richard Harris), a horse-swapper by trade, offered Eamon three horses for the now fully grown, beautiful Awbonnie, so that his unbalanced son, Talbot (River Phoenix), can have a wife to comfort him, Eamon accepted the offer since he needed the horses at the time. During childbirth, Awbonnie died along with the child, and Prescott's son has become completely deranged with her loss, while the ghost of Awbonnie torments him further and curses him for having his father buy her, as he converses with her ghost, refusing to leave the sight of the dead body.

As the film opens, the tormented Prescott, willing to do anything he can to save his son, returns to see Eamon to purchase his other half-breed daughter thinking he can restore his son's sanity with her as a replacement. But Reeves strongly objects and because of that Eamon changes his mind about the sale, which prompts Prescott to kidnap Velada.

The barren landscape is frighteningly populated by impressionable children, con men, dwarves, acrobats, comics, a Greek Chorus singing about the tragedy while strumming on their bluegrass instruments, Indians hunting on the plains, angry frontiersmen, a lone man walking through the desert with all his possessions on his back, and assorted madmen. When Father and son go to retrieve Velada, the carnival people pack up their equipment and flee without their leader, prepared to carry on the show without him.

Silent Tongue's call for vengeance is being carried out by Awbonnie as a ghost and as a buzzard, as she is also the ghost that trails Prescott to torment him as he brings Velada to his son.

Harris gives a stately performance of a father who doesn't know what else he can do for his son. Bates behaves more like a symbol than a real person, as he represents what the vulgar Europeans were like, who considered themselves superior to the Indians and in their ignorance raped the Indians and the land. Bates says things that shows his disdain for them as heathens, such as: "Indians are born to suffer." In River Phoenix' penultimate role, he mainly babbles and has no chance to show his skills as an actor. Tantoo Cardinal has a minor part, even though the film is theoretically about her, as the film's title states. What becomes overwhelming is the open and spacious landscape, a perfect breeding ground for violence and insanity. It's a film that revels in a dark brooding mystical flavor and of being a revisionist-type of a Western rather than one of those traditional oaters. Unfortunately, the film never held together in a cohesive way, and seemed forced and awkward at times. It should satisfy mostly those who are in need to see something different, something that is cultish and attuned to Sam Shephard's penchant for showing dysfunctional families.

    REVIEWED ON 2/5/2001     GRADE: C+

Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"

    http://www.sover.net/~ozus

    ozus@sover.net

© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED DENNIS SCHWARTZ

The review above was posted to the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due to ASCII to HTML conversion.

Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews