# As Good As It Gets (1997)

### reviewed by
David Wilcock

    AS GOOD AS IT GETS
    (TRI-STAR)
    RUNNING TIME: 138 MINUTES (2 hours 18 minutes)
     STARRING JACK NICHOLSON, HELEN HUNT AND GREG KINNEAR
     DIRECTED BY JAMES L. BROOKS

James L. Brooks, one of the developers of The Simpsons and director of Broadcast News, returns to the big screen with this entertaining, if slightly flawed comedy. Nicholson plays Melvin Udall, probably the most horrible person ever on the screen. He's racist, homophobic, and never has a good word to say to anyone. So, nobody talks to him, except waitress Carol Conelly (T.V sitcom star Hunt, who was last seen in Twister, 1996). Naturally, Udall, Conelly and gay neighbor Simon Bishop (Kinnear) who Nicholson hates, all hit it off in the end.

Like Good Will Hunting (1997) and Titanic (1997), even though the outcome is completely obvious, As Good As It Gets is an enjoyable, funny and warm comedy. Nicholson is hilarious as Melvin, churning out insults with superb relish. Only Nicholson could get away with the lines that Melvin delivers. Hunt is also good as waitress Carol, and easily rises to the challenge of Nicholson. There's also (thankfully) a bit of chemistry between them. Kinnear, as the gay neighbor, seems to have a slightly underwritten role, he's more of a plot convience than a character. Although his performance is good, his character just seems to exist to help Melvin and Carol come together. In fact, the scene stealer is Simon's dog, who is funnier than Nicholson. But then again, pets are always cute on screen.

Providing solid support is Cuba Gooding, Jnr (Jerry Maguire, 1996) and Yeardly Smith (who is the voice of Lisa Simpsons in The Simpsons) Although Gooding isn't as good as is character in Maguire, he is still fun. He overacts a little, but not so much as to be annoying. Smith is also good, although she has a fairly small role. Even director Lawrence Kasdan (Body Heat, 1981) makes an appearance as a doctor.

But this is primarily Nicholsons film, and every scene he's in, he's steals it. He's character is so hateful, though, it's amazing that anyone talks to him at all, especially Carol. And this is the films main problem. It's totally unbelievable that Carol would ever consider liking Melvin. She doesn't fall in love with him naturally, the film forces her to fall in love with him. Also, Melvins character seems to go too nice, too quickly. I would doubt anyone with a character like Melvins would be able to turn back to a nice, loving person. It would take a helluva long time, much longer than this film would like to make out. Brooks direction is good, though, if a bit average, but he usually manages to get an emotion out of the audience. He handles the comedy scenes better than the sentimental ones (he tends to pile on to much schmaltz) but generally he's good. There's also a nice soundtrack by veteran composer Hans Zimmer.

But, generally, As Good As It Gets achieves what it sets out to do, which is to make the audience feel good by the end of the movie. The movie is a bit overlong, but Nicholson is such good fun that the running time passes by pretty quickly. Overall, As Good As It Gets is a fun movie, even though it may be unbelivable, and certainly worth seeing (if just for Jack Nicholsons performance.) Not quite As Good As It Gets (pardon the bad joke), but still good fun.

    OVERALL RATING: ***1/2 OUT OF *****
    1998 David Wilcock

    DAVID WILCOCK
    david.wilcock@btinternet.com
    Visit the Wilcock Movie Page!
    http://wilcockmovie.home.ml.org -OR-
    http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/9061

The review above was posted to the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due to ASCII to HTML conversion.

Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews