# Vida es silbar, La (1998)

### reviewed by
Dennis Schwartz

LIFE IS TO WHISTLE (Vida es silbar, La) (director/writer: Fernando Perez; screenwriters: Humberto Jimenez/ Eduardo Del Llano; cinematographer: Paul Perez Ureta; editor: Julia Yip; cast: Luis Alberto Garcia (Elpidio Valdes), Coralia Veloz (Julia), Claudia Rojas (Mariana), Bebe Perez (Bebe), Isabel Santos (Chrissy), Joan Manuel Reyes (Ismael), Rolando Brito (Dr. Fernando), 1998-Cuba)

    Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz

A modern day comedy taking place in Havana, Cuba, that is laced with supernatural implications, as it is directed with artful flourishes by Fernando Perez. In the pulsating background, capturing the whimsical mood of those who live in Havana, is the staccato music of Bola de Nieve and Benny More. But the film suffers greatly in making every single thing that happens pertain to a heavy-handed metaphorical symbol. The hallucinatory story, as a result, is dumbed-down, so much so, that it loses whatever strength and vision it might have had.

The three main characters, whose story is linked through the orphanage, and one of them even has a mother named Cuba, that is, in case you don't get that their stories are metaphors about the economic and political situation in Communist Cuba. These three Cubans internalize their personal struggles and strivings for happiness, as the film intersects their tales by cutting from one character to the next, which makes all their stories seem fuzzy. The three will eventually meet on Saint Barbara's Day, December 4, in the Revolutionary Square, to see what their fate is.

The film is playfully narrated by the 18-year-old Bebe (Bebe Perez) as if she was a teenage Guardian Angel to the three, who is seen in her narration in different locations and even underwater. Why she is the narrator, is not clear, but she was an orphan with two of the other characters and learned to whistle before she could speak, which upset her teachers.

The film opens with a quote from John Lennon: Life is what happens to you while you are busy doing other things. The film is heavy with quotes like that one, as if these cute little slogans can really explain life in Cuba.

The only one of the three stories that I found bearable, was about the slender and attractive Mariana (Claudia Rojas). She is a promiscuous ballerina. She is so interested in getting the starring part in Giselle, that she makes a vow of chastity with God, that if she gets the part, she will never sleep with another man.

She gets the part, and her dance partner is a dream come true, Ismael (Joan Manuel Reyes). This leaves her in a tormented state, as he can't understand why they don't make love, as she puts everything into the dance and becomes Giselle, but is frustrated that she can't be with him.

Elpidio Valdes (Luis Alberto Garcia), a scrappy young musician, scam artist, and fisherman, abandoned by his mother Cuba, who is wracked with guilt because he hasn't lived up to her expectations of him. He even has a tattoo on his back shoulder telling of his love for his mother. Elpidio's chance to change comes when he steals money from the bag of a tourist, Chrissy (Isabel Santos), a Greenpeace worker with a shaved head, who comes into Cuba in a hot-air balloon. He returns the bag with all her credit cards but without the money and the two carry on a hot affair, as he brings her fish every day to keep the romance going. When she is about to leave, she tells him she will be back in a month to see him or he can leave with her now to the United States. We know he has changed for sure, when he burns out his tattoo for his mother, and tells her that he stole her money.

The most trite tale, is of Julia (Coralia Veloz), a middle-aged do-gooder, the disconsolate social aid to the elderly, who is subject to fits of yawning and fainting spells set off by the word "sex." Taken by her friend to consult a psychiatrist, she uncovers a traumatic love affair in her past, which she has repressed for the last twenty years. The filmmaker gives Freud the importance of someone just being discovered and repeating his theories as if they were fresh instead of the cliches they have become to the Western world.

The film lost its focus and painted an artificially whimsical picture of Cuba, that was hardly relevant or enlightening. Whatever pleaure there was in the film, came from its splendid ballet numbers, the beautiful artistic framing of its shots, and its bouncy music. But that was outweighed by how it was weighed down from its symbolism.

    REVIEWED ON 5/25/99                GRADE: C-

Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"

    http://www.sover.net/~ozus

    ozus@sover.net

© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED DENNIS SCHWARTZ

The review above was posted to the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due to ASCII to HTML conversion.

Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews