# Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (1999)

### reviewed by
Brian Adelstein

Star Wars I- The Phantom Menace (Review)

    **** Stars out of ****

Short Background/ Why Star Wars fans SHOULD love this Movie

I would like to personally start off by mentioning that I am NOT a die hard Star Wars fan and have never been one. I did enjoy the original trilogy, but I found Empire Strikes Back (1980) to be one of the most boring films of all time as no one really died and no special "war" took place. The whole Hoth scene was simply filler. I think people have been mystified by the unbelievable relevation "Luke, I am your father!" and have gone ga-ga over it more than anything else As for Return of the Jedi, I think my enjoyment quickly ended when Teddy Ruxpin and his buddies started slugging the empire. I mean, come on! I was laughing my way through the whole thing. That leaves us here, almost sixteen years later. Would Star Wars go back to its cutsie roots from Jedi or bore us to sleep like Empire? I am happy to say, definately NEITHER.

    The TRUTH

Star Wars: The Phantom Menace has to be considered one of the best films of the year, definately better than the last two sagas. I mean, think about this: There were REAL ACTORS in this film!! Sit back and think about it: Mark Hamill has done nothing since the trilogy and Carrie Fisher has disappeared off the face of the earth too. The only actor of any merit who survived was Harrison Ford, and he hadn't learned how to act by the original trilogy either. Liam Neeson and Ewan MacGregor were masterful in their roles and kept me smiling the whole way through. Ewan even mimiced Sir Alec to a certain extent! As for the rest, Natalie Portman did her job and little Jake Lloyd was fine too. I mean, did you really expect to hear those infamous hissing noises from a little boy? Give me a break...he played the role very well. Lastly, I really LIKED Jar-Jar Binks. His so called "accent" was not intentional in my humble opininon. He was just a little side kick who did his job. For your information, I truly HATED C-3PO from the original trilogy. Talk about an annoying piece of space trash! All he could say was "You did it!" and "Oh my, Ive forgotten how much I hate space travel" yada, yada, yada. Let it go. I let C-3PO go too. What made this episode really special were the action scenes and REAL intellectual stimulation. Just in case you didn't catch it, (and LOTS of you didn't, unfortunately) "Master" Darth Sidious IS the Emperor from the first Trilogy and Senator Palpatine is one and the same. That is the whole concept of the Phantom Menace: Darth Sidious was the one wrecking havoc on the Star Wars universe by making an issue out of an otherwise non-important "trade" dispute and influencing Princess Amidala to have himself promoted in the Senate. Consequently, the victory on the planet down below was a hollow one and probably "forseen!". As far as the action scenes, they were much better than the original trilogy as well. Darth Sidious may not have talked, but he was pure evil nontheless. As far as I am concerned, if Phantom Menace is heralding similar sequels, I am happy for it. If I wanted the original trilogy, I would wish for bad acting and a silly, brainless love triangle in space/evil father/ soap operal plot. Phantom has none of the above. What a fantastic film!!

    -Brian Adelstein

The review above was posted to the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due to ASCII to HTML conversion.

Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews