# What Lies Beneath (2000)

### reviewed by
Dennis Schwartz

WHAT LIES BENEATH (director: Robert Zemeckis; screenwriter: Clark Gregg/based on a story by Sarah Kernochan & Gregg; cinematographer: Don Burgess; editor: Arthur Schmidt; cast: Harrison Ford (Norman Spencer), Michelle Pfeiffer (Claire Spencer), Diana Scarwid (Jody), Miranda Otto (Mary Feur), James Remar (Warren Feur), Joe Morton (Dr. Drayton), Amber Valletta (Madison Elizabeth Frank), Victoria Birdwell (Beatrice), Katharine Towne (Caitlin Spencer); Runtime: 126; 2000)

    Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz

A mindless psychological thriller set in Vermont, that starts out in a promising mysterious fashion but ends badly, ruining any credibility it might have generated. It tries very hard to be both a mystery and a supernatural story, but it goes off course on both its aims way before it sinks to its low abyss. It was a film that was all foreplay but couldn't come to a climax, and as the film started to clear up the mystery mood it created while moving at its snail pace, the revelations of the mystery weren't worth exploring. The only thing the film did well, was provide a lot of schlock.

The result is a dull film, with uninteresting and poorly developed characters, and too many manipulative fright scenes that I have seen before in too many other horror flicks. The only thing this film did really well aside from all its schlock setups, was photograph the lakeside Lake Champlain area and use the Champlain Bridge for some eerie shots. The story seemed to drag from the onset, as the director wasted time taking irrelevant long shots aimed to be frightening and then turning away from those shots without drawing anything out of them; it should have been an eighty minute film, like the B- movies of the 1950s, and then it might have been a more tolerable venture. Robert Zemeckis ("Forrest Gump"/"Contact"/"Back to the Future") is such an emotionally empty director, his characters seem more like robots than humans, that the movie seems to be such an effort in draining the life out of it that it becomes mostly a special effect movie with characters becoming secondary in importance.

Zemeckis has built a story around a lady-in-peril, one with too much idle time, who is overwrought with a healthy dose of neurotic tension, talking herself into thinking she sees ghosts, but who doesn't know how to internalize that fright. Michelle Pfeiffer is asked to carry this film, but without an adequate script, even if she is a good casting decision for that role, her task is too difficult to accomplish.

Norman Spencer (Harrison Ford) is a genius in genetics and has moved to Vermont to accept the prestigious Dupont seat at the university. He is doing lab reseach at the same university his father taught at. Claire (Michelle Pfeiffer) is the beautiful cellist who gave up her career to marry the genius. She comes with some baggage, she had a daughter (Towne) by another man before she married Ford. Claire is a little unnerved that her daughter has just been enrolled in an away college and that she will be left alone in the house. The couple has just completed the fixing up of their stately manse, and the roses in the garden, that Michelle takes such pride in, look wonderful in the early New England autumn. Everything seems blissful between the Spencers, now that she has recovered from the car accident she had a year ago.

Claire is upset that her new neighbors, the Feurs (Miranda Otto & James Remar), are loudly fighting outside in their driveway, where the Spencers can plainly hear them (Jimmy Stewart did that eavesdropping part in "Rear Window"). On one occasion Mary is uncontrollably sobbing in her yard but is unreceptive to Claire's willingness to help, as they converse through a wooden fence. Mary mysteriously blurts out that she believes she will just disappear one day, a statement that frightens Claire into believing that her husband is a killer. Norman checks out Warren Feur to calm his wife's fears, and finds out that the psychology professor at the university, is completely harmless. These suspicions of hers come to a fruitless conclusion, as Claire hysterically lashes out at Warren for murdering his wife when she is not seen for a few days, but when his wife makes her grand entrance at the university function, to the chagrin of Norman and the terrible embarrassment for Claire, the Feurs disappear from the picture as possible suspects to their haunted house.

The film then moves into the supernatural for its story and the typical Hollywood ghost story scenes: doors mysteriously open, a solitaire game on a computer is flashing the initials of the local university coed who has been missing for a year, a stereo system turns on unaided, a bathtub fills up by itself, and most importantly, visions of the dead girl (Amber Valletta) Norman had a secret affair with a year ago, the green-eyed blonde vixen, keep popping up whenever Michelle is home alone.

Pfeiffer in the meantime has turned a ghostly pale color for the remainder of the film and has become hysterically possessed by the ghost she keeps seeing in the house. She starts losing contact with her workaholic hubby, who is more enmeshed in the paper he is to present in New Haven than with her hysterics. So she turns to her divorced friend (Diana Scarwid) for psychic advice, but is given only cynical giggles for help. Upon her husband's request, she also sees a dogmatic Freudian shrink (Morton), as the film wastes too much time on these dead-end trails.

The last shocking scene takes place in a bathtub, one that could have been ordered from the Sears catalogue before World War 11, and seems to be ready-made for a horror flick. Michelle will lie in the tub drugged and in a paralysed state awaiting her fate, as the water rises. All the edgy middle-aged lady did, was bring up ghosts from the past and now someone must answer for those buried lies that brought on the ghosts.

If this is supposed to be like a Hitchcockian thriller, then why wasn't I thrilled by what I saw!

Zemeckis has created an unaffecting haunted house thriller, with samples from many other films thrown into this derivative stew, but nothing seems to work here. This is just a boring movie about a couple that are as unreal as the ghosts in their house.

    REVIEWED ON 7/25/2000     GRADE: C

Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"

    http://www.sover.net/~ozus

    ozus@sover.net

© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED DENNIS SCHWARTZ

The review above was posted to the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup (de.rec.film.kritiken for German reviews).
The Internet Movie Database accepts no responsibility for the contents of the review and has no editorial control. Unless stated otherwise, the copyright belongs to the author.
Please direct comments/criticisms of the review to relevant newsgroups.
Broken URLs inthe reviews are the responsibility of the author.
The formatting of the review is likely to differ from the original due to ASCII to HTML conversion.

Related links: index of all rec.arts.movies.reviews reviews